Yahya ibn Ya’mur narrated, “The first man who spoke about qadar (divine decree) in Basra was Ma'bad Al-Juhany. Humaid ibn Abderrahman Al-Hemyary and I set out for pilgrimage - or umrah - and said, ‘If we can only meet someone of the Prophet’s companions ﷺ, we will ask him about what those people are saying about qadar. Accidentally, we saw Abdullah ibn Omar ibn Al-Khattab while he was entering the mosque. My companion and I surrounded him, one on his right and the other on his left. I expected that my companion would authorize me to speak so I said, ‘O Abu Abdurrahman! We have some people in our land who recite the Quran and seek knowledge [he added some of their affairs as they claim that there is no divine decree and events were not predestined].’ Abdullah ibn Omar said, ‘If you meet such people, tell them that I am neither from them nor they are from me. By whom Abdullah ibn Umar swears, if any one of them had given charity of gold equal to the mountain of Uhud, Allah would not have accepted it unless he had believed in the divine decree.’ He further said, ‘My father, Omar ibn al-Khattab, told me, ‘Once we were sitting with the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, a man with deep white clothes and deep black hair came. He neither had signs of travel on him nor any of us recognized him. He sat with the Prophet ﷺ, placed his knees next to the Prophet’s knees and his palms on the Prophet’s thighs, and said, ‘O Muhammad, inform me about al-Islam.’ The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, ‘Islam is to testify that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, establish prayer, pay Zakat, observe the fast of Ramadan, and perform pilgrimage if you can bear it.’ He (the inquirer) said, ‘You have told the truth.’ He (Omar) said, ‘It amazed us that he asked then verified his truth.’ He (the inquirer) said, ‘Inform me about iman (faith).’ The Prophet said, ‘It is to believe in Allah, His angels, His books, His messengers, the Last Day, and the divine decree, good and evil.’ He (the inquirer) said, ‘You have told the truth.’ He (the inquirer) said, ‘Inform me about ihsan.’ He (the Prophet) said, ‘It is to worship Allah as if you are seeing Him, for though you do not see Him, He sees you.’ He (the enquirer) said, ‘Inform me about the hour (the last day).’ He (the Prophet) said, ‘One who is asked about it does not know more about it than the one who is asking.’ He (the inquirer) said, ‘Inform me about its signs.’ He (the Prophet) said, ‘That the slave-girl will give birth to her mistress, that you will find barefooted, naked, destitute, goat-herds competing with each other in constructing buildings.’ He (Omar) said, ‘Then he (the inquirer) went on his way and I stayed for a long while then the Prophet said to me, ‘Omar, do you know who this inquirer was?’ I replied, ‘Allah and His Messenger know best.’ He (the Prophet) said, ‘He was Gabriel (the angel) who came to instruct you the matters of your religion.’”.
Commentary :
Belief in qadar (divine decree) is one of the fundamentals of the Islamic faith. The Prophet (ﷺ) explained that acting based on lawful means does not contradict it. On the other hand, he warned his nation against those denying divine decree or claiming that it contradicts Islamic faith. This supreme hadith taught us the Islamic religion by clarifying its pillars along with the signs of the Last Day. In this hadith, Yahya ibn Ya’mur reported that the first one who rejected the divine decree was Ma'bad Al-Juhany. He was one of the students of al-Hasan al-Basri. Once he spread his heresy of rejecting the divine decree, Al-Hajjaj imprisoned and killed him. This was in Basra, a city built by Caliph Umar ibn Al-Khattab in the south of Iraq in 17 AH. and inhabited by people in 18 AH. Denying the divine decree means that Allah just knows people's deeds after they occur. His saying, “... in Basra” implies that he was preceded by others who adopted this heresy outside Basra. It was said that this misleading heresy first arose in Mecca when the Kaaba burned and Ibn al-Zubair was trapped by Yazid. Some said it was burned by Allah's decree while others rejected this opinion. It was also said that the first one who rejected the divine decree in Levant was Amr Al-Maqsous. In this hadith, Yahya ibn Ya'mur reported that both he and Humaid ibn Abderrahman Al-Hemyary set out for pilgrimage - or umrah - to the Sacred House in Macca and hoped they met one of the Prophet's companions so they asked him about rejecting the divine decree that some adopted. Accidentally, they saw Abdullah ibn Omar ibn Al-Khattab entering the mosque. They surrounded him, one on his right and the other on his left. Yahya expected that his companion would authorize him to speak due to either his being older or more eloquent than him or that Humaid was too shy to ask. Yahya told Abdullah about what happened and addressed him with his nickname, Abu Abderrahman out of respect. He told him that there were some people in Basra taking much care of the Quran recitation, seeking Islamic knowledge, and spreading some misleading heresies. He mentioned and added some other points so that Abdullah may give them importance. It may mean that he mentioned their doctrine of heresies of denying the divine decree, believing that Allah just knows people's deeds after they occur, proving one's independent ability of Allah, the Almighty, and denying that all things happen based on Allah’s command. When Abdullah ibn Omar heard that, he asked him to inform those people of heresies that he was neither from them nor they were from him, which is a complete repudiation. Then he swore by Allah if any one of them had given charity of gold equal to the mountain of Uhud - a great mountain in Medina -, Allah would not have accepted it unless he had believed in Allah’s divine decree, for believing in the divine decree is one of the faith pillars. Then he told them about the proof of that. He said that his father, Omar ibn al-Khattab, told him that once they were sitting with the Prophet (ﷺ), a man suddenly came to him. He wore deep white clothes and had deep black hair. He had no signs of travel like being exhausted or dusty. None knew about him either. He placed his knees next to the Prophet’s ones and his palms on the Prophet’s thighs or his own thighs. This refers that he deeply knew the Prophet's prestige. He addressed the Prophet ﷺ with his name, not his prophethood nickname. Then he asked the Prophet ﷺ about Islam and its reality. The Prophet ﷺ told him about the five pillars of Islam: (1) To approve by your heart and testify by your tongue that there is no god worthy of worship but Allah and that Muhammad is his Messenger. It is a correlated testimony. It means that a Muslim utters these two testimonies while acknowledging the oneness of Allah and His right to be worshiped alone without any partners. It means that a Muslim believes in Prophet Muhammad's message and acts upon it. This is the testimony that will benefit us in the Hereafter so we will win Paradise and be saved from Hell, (2) Establishing the prayer: It means to regularly perform the five daily obligatory prayers at their times while fulfilling their conditions and pillars. They are Fajr (Dawn), Dhuhr (Noon), Asr (Afternoon), Maghreb (Sunset), and Isha (Evening), (3) Paying the obligatory zakah: It is an obligatory financial act of worship concerning any property that reaches the limit determined by Islam over an entire lunar year. Generally, 2.5% of one’s savings must be given to the poor and the types determined by Islam. It includes all money sources like cattle, livestock, crops, fruits, merchandise, and buried treasure or metals extracted from the earth. Each source has its own percentage and time of paying to the poor, (4) Fasting Ramadan month: It is to refrain from eating, drinking, intercourse, etc. from dawn to sunset, out of worship, and (5) Pilgrimage to the Sacred House once in one's lifetime on the condition that one is financially and physically able to perform it. Once the Prophet ﷺ ﷺ explained the pillars of Islam, the man said to him, "You have told the truth." It means you answered truthfully and correctly, which amazed the attendees, for he asked as if he did not know but he later confirmed the Prophet's answer. Is he a teacher or a learner?! Then he asked the Prophet about the faith's reality. The Prophet ﷺ told him that it includes six pillars as follows: (1) Belief in Allah: It is to believe in His existence, his attributes of majesty and perfection, his oneness, and his being clear of the attributes of imperfection. It is also to believe that he is the Eternal Refuge, neither begets nor is born, nor is there to Him any equivalent. It is to believe that He is the Creator of all creatures and the only god deserving to be worshiped without any partners, who manages his kingdom however he wills, (2) Belief in angels: It is to believe in the forms in which Allah created them. They are a great creation made of light. They are servants without any divine attributes. They are honored servants forced to obey Allah, the Almighty. They do not disobey Allah but do what he commands them to do. Their real number is only known to Allah. In general, they are different types with various jobs. Some are specifically mentioned in the Quran and Prophet's tradition like Gabriel who is responsible for conveying the divine revelation to prophets, Israfil who is responsible for blowing the trumpet, Michael who is responsible for sending the rain, Angel of Death who is responsible for holding people's souls, etc. A Muslim must believe in them as a whole and their specific details if mentioned, (3) Belief in Allah's books: The Quran was revealed to Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, the seal of the Prophets and Messengers, the Torah revealed to Prophet Moses ﷺ, Injil revealed to Prophet Jesus ﷺ, the Psalms revealed to Prophet David ﷺ, and the scriptures of Abraham and Moses ﷺ. Belief in these books means to believe in their unfabricated original versions which were the word of Allah. A Muslim must believe that the Quran is a judge over these books so it may confirm, abrogate, or even correct their reports, (4) Belief in Allah's Messengers: It is to believe that Allah sent human messengers to people to call them to worship Him alone. A Muslim believes in all Prophets and messengers without any distinction. A Muslim believes in Prophet Muhammad, the seal of Prophets and messengers. He was sent to all people so it is obligatory for all people and Jinns to believe in him and follow his message once they hear of him. Whoever disbelieves in his message disbelieves in all prophets and messengers. A Muslim believes that they were guided ones who were sent to guide people, truthful in their messages from Allah, granted miracles that proved their truthfulness, and conveyed Allah's messages without insertion, deletion, or concealing. A Muslim has to love, dignify, support, and take Prophets as role models, (5) Belief in the Last Day: It means to believe in all events of that day like resurrection, gathering people for reckoning, the balance, the path, Paradise which is a reward for good doers, Hell which is a punishment for bad doers, along with other issues that were authentically proven, (6) Belief in the divine decree: It is to believe in Allah's timeless and eternal knowledge which deeply encompasses all issues' quantities and conditions. It is to fully believe that all things, good or evil, sweet or bitter, and beneficial or harmful are made by Allah’s decree, will, and command. It is to believe that Allah, the Almighty, gives people the ability for what they were created for. The man said, “You have told the truth.” This proves that belief in the divine decree is a pillar of faith and that Ma’bad al-Juhany’s denial is incorrect and contradictory to the Prophet’s statement and Gabriel’s testimony. In this hadith, the Prophet ﷺ explained the principle of faith which is the inner ratification and the principle of Islam which is the outward surrender and submission. This means that every believer is a Muslim not vice versa and that belief is the heart’s act while Islam is the limbs’ act. Then the man asked the Prophet (ﷺ) about ihsan which is related to one’s relationship with Allah, not with people. The Prophet answers, “It is to worship Allah as if you are seeing Him, for though you do not see Him, He sees you.” The top level of ihsan is to worship Allah as if you are seeing him with your heart and insight. If he finds it hard, he moves to the other level which is to worship Allah while realizing He is seeing and knowing his secrets and outward issues, and nothing may hide from Him. Then the man asked him about the time of the hereafter. The Prophet (ﷺ) answered, “One who is asked about it does not know more about it than the one who is asking.” It means that all people are equally unaware of its time. This indicates that he is Allah alone who knows its time. In the Two Sahihs, Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet ﷺ said, "Five issues that Allah alone knows." He recited Allah's saying, “Indeed, Allah [alone] has knowledge of the Hour and sends down the rain and knows what is in the wombs. And no soul perceives what it will earn tomorrow, and no soul perceives in what land it will die.” (Luqman: 34) These are the keys to the unseen world that Allah only knows. The man said to the Prophet, "Then inform me about its signs." He meant the signs indicating its approach so people may take care, repent, and return to Allah. The Prophet (ﷺ) mentioned some of its signs such as: (1) "A slave girl will give birth to her mistress." In the Two Sahih, Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet ﷺ said, " ... her lord." It means her owner and guardian. It was said that it may refer to the abundant disobedience to one's parents in which he deals with his mother as her lord. It was also said that it may refer to Muslims' frequent conquests of unbelievers' countries in which a young slave girl is brought, set free in the Islamic country, embraces Islam, and buys her mother in ignorance of this case so she becomes her mistress, which has already existed. It was also said that a slave girl may give birth to a king so his mother will be among his slaves, (2) "That you will find barefooted, naked, destitute, goat-herds competing with each other in constructing buildings." It means they are competing for their height and abundance without thanking Allah who bestowed on them after poverty, which is proven by the Prophet's hadith in Ahmad and Termidhy when he says, "The Hour will not be established until the happiest people in the world is Luka' ibn Luka'." Afterward, the man went and Omar stayed for a long while then the Prophet asked him, "O Omar, do you know who this inquirer was?" Omar replied, "Allah and His Messenger know best." The Prophet answered him that it was Gabriel (the angel) who "came to instruct you the matters of your religion." Gabriel, the Angel, was the reason for the Prophet's answering and teaching his companions this abundant knowledge of Islam and the Hereafter. Finally, this hadith contains the following benefits: (1) Clarifying Islam's five pillars and faith's six pillars, (2) Mentioning some etiquette of the seeker of Islamic knowledge as modesty, (3) Proving the blessing of seeking knowledge, (4) Knowledge benefits both questioners and answerers, (5) Referring to Prophet's companions' good manners with him, (6) Illustrating Gabriel's forms when meeting the Prophet, (7) Stating the predecessors' attitudes about denying heresies, (8) Mentioning some sects opposing Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah such as Al-Qadareyyah, (9) Desirability of elegant clothes and cleanliness when meeting scholars and kings, for Gabriel came and taught people with his words and appearance, and (11) Reprehending of unnecessary construction..
Hadiths
