1084
Narrated Ibraheem that he heard `AbdurRahmaan bin Yazeed saying: We offered a four-units prayer at Minaa behind ‘Uthmaan bin `Affaan. `Abdullah bin Mas`ood was informed about it so he said, "Truly to Allah we belong and truly to Him we shall return." then added, "I prayed two units with Allah's Messenger ﷺ at Minaa and similarly with Abu Bakr and with `Umar (during their caliphates)." He further said, " May my good fortune from the two units of the four [that I performed] be accepted by Allah.".
Commentary :
The Companions (may Allah be pleased with them) were the most eager of people in following the guidance of the Prophet ﷺ and be in conformity to his sunnah. They would go over one another’s [actions] in any situation that took place if appeared not according to the sunnah of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.
In this hadeeth, the taabiʿee, ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn Yazeed reports that he and others were with ʿUthmaan ibn ʿAffaan(may Allah be pleased with him) at Minaa - which is a valley near the Sacred Precinct of Makkah that the pilgrims descend into on the Day of Tarwiyah, which is the eighth of DhulHijjah; and that was during the time of his caliphate. He mentioned that they performed a prayer of four units, meaning they did not shorten the prayers which consist of four units. Then, ʿAbdullah ibn Masʿood(may Allah be pleased with him) was informed of that, thus, said: “Verily, we belong to Allah and to Him we shall return.” Then, he (may Allah be pleased with him) reported that he prayed with the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, Abu Bakr, and ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭaab(may Allah be pleased with them) - each during their time [as caliphs] - while they were performing the Hajj at Minaa. All of them shortened the prayers that consist of four units, namely Dhuhr, ʿAsr, and ʿIshaa’, to two prayer units. Then, he (may Allah be pleased with him) said: “May my good fortune from the two units of the four [that I performed] be accepted by Allah.” Meaning: ‘May my share of the two prayer units be accepted as a substitute for the four units.’ By that statement, he was alluding to the action of ʿUthmaan(may Allah be pleased with him). It is as if he is saying: ‘I wished ʿUthmaan shortened the prayer just like what the Prophet ﷺ, Abu Bakr, and ʿUmar did.’ His intention [here] was to show that diverging from what the Messenger of Allah ﷺ and his two Companions had done is disliked.
However, Ibn Masʿood had performed four unitsbehind ʿUthmaan(may Allah be pleased with them both) according to the report documented by Aboo Dawood, where it has been said to him by someone: ‘You criticized ʿUthmaan, and yet you, yourself, prayed four units [here before]?!’ He replied: “Discord is evil”, meaning, that dissension and quarrelling between Muslims in that place (Minaa) is evil, and worse than insisting on two prayer units and opposing the Imaam - indicating that it is permissible to perform the full four prayer units - even if it differs from the preferable view. This is an important principle, specifically in discretionary matters where many viewpoints are valid and possible. It is incumbent upon the scholars to adhere to what the leader chooses - so long as he sees the benefit in it, and that the matter is not fixed [i.e., immutable] by the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.
Al-Bukhaaree narrated a hadeeth, [on the authority] of Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with him), where he relates that ʿUthmaan(may Allah be pleased with him) shortened the prayer [for Hajj at Minaa] at the start of his caliphate, then he [later switched it by] performing the prayer in its entirety. It has been said with regards to ʿUthmaan(may Allah be pleased with him) completing the prayer in its entirety that: he exercised ijtihaad[i.e., making an independent legal judgement] on the matter; because he believed that the Prophet ﷺ was given the choice either to shorten the prayer or pray it in its entirety, or otherwise [when the situation allowed for it]. He ﷺ chose the easier option of the two for his community - and ʿUthmaan(may Allah be pleased with him) took the harder option for himself and left the dispensation [of being able to shorten the prayer], because that was permissible for him due to the ruling of choice, as Allah, Most High, permitted in it.
It has [also] been said that ʿUthmaan ibn ʿAffaan(may Allah be pleased with him) completed the respective prayer[s] in their entirety for the sake of the Bedouins who attended the Hajj that year as they were many in number. He led the people in prayer and performed the four units; so that he could let them know that some prayers consist of four units. On the Hajj, the people take matters of the religion from the imaams and scholars that were present there. For this reason, he feared that some of them would think that the prayer was only two units; thus, he opted for performing the four-unit prayers in their entirety, so that the ignorant and Bedouin could learn. Other interpretations have [also] been said on this matter..